Comparison: DP2 Merrill vs. Sigma SD1M & 30mm f/1.4 ART


deutsch_s1

I’ve already compared the DP2M to the 30mm f/1.4 EX (Part 1,Part 2) and discovered that DP’s lens is much sharper. I’ve also compared the two 30mm lenses, the EX and the new ART (Part 1,Part 2). The only thing left to do is to compare the DP2M with the new ART on the SD1M. Can DP2M‘s tiny 30mm f/2.8 win once more?

DP2M-VS-30-mm-f-1.4

Although performance-wise it is much closer to the 30mm f/2.8 than the EX, not even the ART manages to dethrone DP2M’s standard prime. One interesting aspect of the 30/1.4 ART is the difference between short range and long range performance. At short range (wooden boards) even at wide open aperture of f/1.4 it is sharp in the centre. Stopped down to f/2.8 its centre performance is on the same level with 30mm f/2.8 on the DP2M. If you compare the edges however, you immediately see why the 30/2.8 respectively the DP2M has such a great reputation. It‘s sharper across the entire aperture range. At long range the 30/2.8 even manages to expand its lead. While the ART takes a performance (sharpness) hit, the 30/2.8 retains its exceptional resolving power regardless of the subject distance. It is this combination of excellent performance, regardless of the distance to the subject, and even sharpness across the entire frame what I like about the DP2M the most. It is mind-boggling how Sigma has managed to pack such high optical performance into a lens this small. If it offered f/1.4 maximum aperture, which would be physically impossible, I wouldn’t have bought the 30mm f/1.4 ART. As matters stand, the ART remains a necessary evil. 😉

And now let’s get to the photos, so that everyone can form their own opinion. (click on the photos to view them on flickr in full resolution)

Sigma DP2 Merrill

long range
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/2.8 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/2.8
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/4 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/4
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/5.6 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/5.6
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/8 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/8
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/11(volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/11
short range
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/2.8 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/2.8
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/4 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/4
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/5.6 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/5.6
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/8 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/8
Sigma DP2 Merrill @ f/11 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/11

Sigma 30mm f/1.4 ART & SD1 Merrill
long range
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/1.4 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/1.4
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/2(volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/2
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/2.8 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/2.8
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/4 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/4
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/5.6 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/5.6
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/8 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/8
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/11 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/11
close range
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/1.4 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/1.4
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/2 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/2
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/2.8 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/2.8
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/4 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/4
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/5.6 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/5.6
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/8 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/8
Sigma SD1 Merrill & 30mm f/1.4 ART @ f/11 (volle Auflösung - full resolution)
f/11

You can find more of my images here:

  1. […] the 30mm f/1.4 Art and DP2M comparison, I discovered that the 30mm Art comes close to the DP2M and its outstanding 30/2.8 lens at close […]

    Reply

  2. […] and here, I compared the DP2M with the 30mm EX, here and here the 30mm EX with the 30mm Art and here the 30mm Art with the […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: